articlePage.html

|
 |
|
Last Updated: Jun 7, 2009 - 5:10:56 AM |
Tibetan Researcher On Changing Herder Lifestyles
A Report from U.S. Embassy Beijing January 1998
A Tibetan social scientist who spent six months of 1997 with
Tibetan herders spoke with U.S. Embassy Beijing Science officer about
changes in rural areas of the Tibetan Autonomous Region. The researcher
described the changes in the lives of Tibetan herders since they settled
into winter quarters. Fixed winter quarters facilitate schooling and
medical care for children yet some older Tibetans fear that increased
outside influences, including Hong Kong kungfu movies on television, are
taking their grandchildren away from traditional Tibetan ways. Rodent
infestations damage the grasslands yet Tibetans will not kill them out
because of their strong religious convictions. China's family planning
regulations and the Marriage Law of the PRC are not enforced in rural
Tibet. Recent oil exploration indicates that northern Tibet probably has
very large oil reserves. The appendix summarizes a 1996 article by
Beijing University Prof. Ma Rong on the Tibetan and ethnic Han
populations of Tibet. Large central government subsidies and food
shipments of 200 kg. per capita per year support Tibet. The number of
ethnic Han teachers and specialists in Tibet fell during the 1980s but
more recently some ethnic Han farmers have moved into the Lhasa region,
subletting land from Tibetans. Unreliable population data makes it hard
to determine how many ethnic Han (about 4 percent of the population in
1990) have moved to Tibet is difficult. Ma called for more research work
on Han in-migration and for the establishment of in-migration controls
if necessary out of religious and cultural considerations. /
Religious Faith Strong in Rural Tibet
A Tibetan social scientist who spend six months doing fieldwork in the
Tibetan Autonomous Region during 1997 spoke with Embassy Science officer
about changes in Tibetan rural life. Religion is a central part of daily
life for the Tibetans, said The researcher. Many women become nuns, but
unlike in earlier times, they return home during the busy season to help
the family with herding. When someone dies, a relative will often give a
cow to the local temple. Often an older Tibetan herders will give all
his property and livestock to the temple when his wife dies, since he
has lived a good life and does not need much to get along.
Well-decorated altars are to be seen in most Tibetan homes.
Rodent Plague on the Grasslands
During the six months of 1997 that the researcher lived with Tibetan
herders and farmers in eastern Tibet, he observed that rodent
infestation of the grasslands have seriously damaged some of the
pastureland of Eastern Tibet. Tibetan herders will not kill the rodents
out of religious scruples, The researcher noticed, even if the rodent is
walking next to them. They fear that the rodent's angry soul would
pursue them. The Tibetans do not object to other people, such as ethnic
Han residents of Tibet, killing the rodents however.
Changing Diet
Han cultural influence, central government subsidies and food shipments
from inner China have brought changes in the Tibetan diet. The
researcher observed how rice has now become a staple of the Tibetan
diet. The researcher noted how even Tibetan herders in remote parts of
Tibet often eat rice at their noonday meal. The herders generally buy
rice twice a year from the Hui nationality herders who dominate commerce
in rural Tibet.
Herders Into Winter Quarters: Gains and Cultural Change
In eastern Tibet, as in neighboring Qinghai Province, many ethnic
Tibetan herders have settled into winter quarters where they spent three
or so months every year rather than migrating continually. The
researcher observed that young Tibetan adults appreciate the winter food
stocks for the animals and the improved access to medical care and
education their children have in the winter quarters. Older Tibetans
dislike the winter settlements, seeing them as a break with Tibetan
traditions. The elders are deeply disturbed to watch Tibetan children
pick up bad influences from television including Hong Kong kungfu
movies. The old people and the children remain in the winter quarters
for schooling when the younger adults move out and travel with herds
during the warmer months.
The settling of herders into permanent winter quarters began in 1985 and
has been done on a large scale since 1991. In some counties of eastern
Tibet the researcher visited, including Andou County, all the herders
have been settled into winter quarters provided at no cost by the
Chinese central government. The government also pays full cost for an
enclosure for the winter grazing area. The herders in Tibet, unlike the
Tibetans of neighboring Qinghai and Sichuan Provinces, pay nothing for
this housing. Each small settlement contains 8 - 10 families and is
separated from nearby settlements by 2 - 3 kilometers. An area enclosed
by a fence protects a winter food supply for livestock.
Settled Herders Acquire Property, Closer Links to Commodity Economy
Tibetan herders do not market their products in the city but instead
sell to Hui nationality middlemen who bring their pastoral products to
the city marketplace. The researcher said that the wandering merchants
of Tibet are generally of the Hui nationality; Tibetans are not usually
traders. Herders are generally unaware of the city market prices and so
do not consider marketing their products themselves in the city, said
the researcher. Tibetan lifestyles are changing as herders settle into
fixed winter quarters. As they acquire more personal property (herders
have few possessions) and develop closer links with the commodity
economy. The researcher remarked that the values and cultures of the
herders change as they acquire property such as furniture and television
which they did not have as nomads. Young people sometimes move into the
cities to work in restaurants or to fix shoes. When finding work becomes
difficult young people return to their land or the herd of their family.
Tibet, the Welfare State -- Pluses and Minuses of Government Support
Ethnic Tibetans outside Tibet often say that the Tibetans in Tibet
proper are lazy, says the researcher. The researcher said that decades
of subsidies from the central government which provide free food,
education and clothing to many Tibetans has sapped their self-reliance.
Tibetans in the Tibetan Autonomous Region need not pay many taxes and
fees (such as road tolls) that ethnic Tibetans in Qinghai and Sichuan
Provinces must pay. Once all school supplies were free, but many
students did not take care of their free school supplies. Now a small
fee is charged. Although the subsidies help people, there is a down side
to the reliance of many Tibetans on government largesse, said the
researcher.
Family Planning, Marriage Laws Not Enforced in Rural Tibet
According to the researcher, family planning is not enforced in rural
Tibet, although government cadres working in the city fall under the
family planning rules. Han cadres can have one child and Tibetan cadres
two children in the city. There is family planning propaganda work and
some voluntary family planning but no enforcement of family planning
regulations in the countryside.
The Marriage Law of the PRC is not enforced in Tibet and the traditional
Tibetan marriage custom of two brothers sharing one wife is still
widespread. When two brothers have the same wife, family property need
not be divided. This helps the family get richer. As a result of this
prosperity, said the researcher, two brother-one wife families have
higher status in Tibet than conventional monogamous marriages. Tibet
with an increasing population and fixed land resources will need to face
its population problem.
Press Report: Oil Exploration Shows Large Reserves Likely on North
Tibet High Plateau
The China Geology and Mining Industry News [Zhongguo Dizhi Kuangchan
Bao] on October 2, 1997 reported that an exploration team organized by
Wuhan Geology University [Wuhan Dizhi Daxue] and a prospecting team from
the South China Petroleum Bureau [Zhongnan Shiyouju] concluded a
"successful" exploration of the Qiangtang [STC: 5018 1048] basin of
northern Tibet. The Qiangtang Basin is an unihabited area situated at
over 5100 meters above sea level. The team found that that the
sedimentary layer is very thick and the Mesozoic Erathem, a geologic
boundary favorable to the creation of petroleum, is found over an area
of over 400,000 square kilometers. Moreover the 65 million to 200
million year old Cretaceous and Jurassic marine sedimentary layers
likely to bear oil are nearly 10,000 meters thick. Chinese experts
believe, the article said, that this area of northern Tibet, along with
the Tarim Basin, will supply important strategic oil reserves to China
in the Twenty-First Century. [Comment: Weak transportation links
handicap oil exploration and any eventual exploitation. The Tibet
highway into Tibet has been improved and a railroad is planned early in
the next century. Building a railroad through the glaciers of Tibet, if
it is even possible, will be a formidable engineering challenge. End
comment]
Appendix: From "China's Minority Populations" -- Tibet
Notes on Tibet chapter from "China's Minority Populations: Surveys and
Research" [Zhongguo Shaoshu Minzu Renkou Diaocha Yanjiu] Chief editors:
Zhang Tianlu, Huang Rongqing No. 8 in the series China's Population in
Transition and Development Published March 1996 by Gaodeng Jiaoyu
Chubanshe. A longer version of these notes which includes notes on the
Mongol and Uighur minorities are on the U.S. Embassy Beijing website at
China's Minority Populations: Mongols, Tibetans, Uighurs
<http://www.redfish.com/USEmbassy-China/sandt/chimin.htm>
Tibet chapter (pp. 34 - 68) was written by Beijing University professor
Ma Rong author of the book "Population and Society of Tibet", published
in December 1996.
Population of Tibet
At the time of the 1990 census, slightly less than half of China's
Tibetan population lived in the Tibetan Autonomous Region: 45.7 percent
(2.1 million people) lived in Tibet while 54.3 percent lived in the ten
Tibetan autonomous districts or counties of the provinces of Qinghai,
Sichuan, Gansu, and Yunnan. In 1990 ethnic Tibetans comprised 95.5
percent of the population of the Tibetan autonomous region. Tibet with a
surface area of over 1.2 million square kilometers is the largest region
in China and occupies one-eighth of the country. The population density
at 1.8 per square kilometer is the lowest in China. The 18 counties
around Lhasa (of Tibet's total 72 counties) contained 34.8 percent of
Tibet's population in 1990. (pp. 34 - 35). In 1990, only 11.5 percent of
Tibet's population lived in cities or towns (chengzhen).
Tibet's Ethnic Tibetan and Ethnic Han Populations
In 1990, the population of the Tibetan autonomous region totaled 2.196
million, including 2.096 million ethnic Tibetans (95.6 percent) and
81,000 ethnic Han (3.7 percent), Menba and Geba minorities each 10,000
at 0.4 percent and 9000 people of other ethnic groups. In 1990, 50.0
percent of the ethnic Han lived in Lhasa (40,387) and 78.2 percent of
the Han lived in Tibet's cities. The ethnic Han population outside Lhasa
was concentrated in six counties which have an average Han population of
4.3 percent; the other 65 counties have an average ethnic Han population
of 0.4 percent.(pp. 36 - 38)
Of the active ethnic Tibetan population, 84.4 percent were engaged in
agriculture, forestry, herding or aquaculture in 1990, down from 89.1
percent in 1982. The proportion engaged in industry rose to 3.1 percent
in 1990 from 1.9 percent in 1982. (pp. 41 - 42)
Tibet's Ethnic Han Population
Between 1982 and 1990, the proportion of specialists in the resident Han
population declined slightly from 25 percent to 18 percent while the
proportion of merchants rose from 2.4 percent to 7.8 percent. Many
ethnic Han are sent to Tibet by the government on three-year contracts.
Between 1982 and 1990, the number of Han specialists in the fields of
health and physical education fell by 660, educators fell by 1200,
geological prospectors fell by 570 and science and technology workers
fell by 400 people. [Note: many young Han intellectuals sent to Tibet
during the Cultural Revolution were allowed to return home after Hu
Yaobang's 1982 visit to Tibet. Hu called for the Tibetanization of
government cadres. The exodus of thousands of Han cadres from Tibet was
so sudden that many hospitals and government offices had difficulty
staying open. End note] The rapid increase in industry in Tibet from a
small base gave new opportunities for Tibetan and ethnic Han merchants,
accounting for the increase in the number of ethnic Han merchants in Tibet.
The increase in the proportion of the ethnic Han population engaged in
agriculture, herding etc. rose from 2.3 percent to 3.4 percent reflects
an increase of 7000 people. Since the contract system in agriculture had
already begun in Tibet by the early 1980s, ethnic Han people moving into
Tibet or already in Tibet switching from some other occupation could not
have been assigned farmland. The increase in the Han population involved
in agriculture etc. must reflect 7000 people going to work in forests,
farms, or ranches newly established or expanded by the government. (p.
46). Over the last several years, some ethnic Han farmers who have made
contracts with local ethnic Tibetan people to grow produce for the Lhasa
market. Most of the Han farmers who have gone to the Lhasa region on
their own over the last few years are temporary residents who moved to
Tibet on their own -- and it is not certain whether their presence has
been fully recorded in the census of the Tibetan autonomous region. More
research needs to be done on this kind of migration into Tibet. (p. 47)
Literacy
The proportion of ethnic Tibetans over age 15 in the Tibetan Autonomous
Region recorded as illiterate or semi-literate in the 1990 census was
72.8 percent compared with the all China national average of 22.8
percent. (p. 51)
Statistics Unreliable
Statistical information is very incomplete for Tibetan because of the
difficulty of gathering information in such a thinly populated area
(especially from nomadic herders), the incompleteness of the reporting
system, and the reluctance of ethnic Tibetans to report deaths in the
family. (pp. 54 - 59). Statistics on migrations between Tibet and other
provinces and between Tibet and neighboring countries are also difficult
to obtain.
Tibetan Population Doubled Since 1949 So Massive Subsidies, Food
Imports Required
Tibet is high, mountainous and cold; relatively little land is suitable
for farming. The population of the Tibetan autonomous region grew from
1.27 million in 1953 to 2.25 million in 1992. In 1992, the Tibetan
autonomous region had 3.36 million mu (225,000 hectares) of arable land
or about 1.5 mu per person. One-third of this land is irrigated and food
production per mu is only 455 jin (230 kg). According to a Chinese
Academy of Sciences study, there is little unused land suitable for
agriculture in Tibet, so increases in production depend upon improved
agricultural techniques, not more land inputs. This in turn will require
considerable new investment in the land and in the people to train them
how to use better techniques.
Fifty Kilograms of Food Per Capita Sent to Tibet Each Year
The Chinese central government in order to meet the needs of this larger
population sends in large quantities of food each year. Between 1985 and
1992, the central government send an average of 106,000 tons per year of
foodstuffs to Tibet. On a per capita basis, this comes to 50 kg. for
each of the 2 million inhabitants of the Tibetan autonomous region. In
1992, about 78 percent of the population was engaged in herding or
agriculture or other primary sector occupations. This means that
although three-quarters of the population is engaged in agriculture and
herding, they still must depend upon the central government to supply
three months worth of food for them every year. If the Tibetan
population continues to increase, the problem of the food supply will
become even more acute. (p. 63)
High Energy Costs But Rich in Hydropower Potential
Tibet does not have coal or oil. Tibet is rich in hydropower potential,
but this resource is very difficult to exploit. Energy costs are so high
that during 1963 - 1988 income from industry was actually negative.
Tibetan agriculture and herding is not self-sufficient and Tibet's
industry loses money. (p. 63) Tibet exports minerals and wood to other
areas of China. Tibet imports food, manufactured goods (mostly goods
needed for light industry), building materials, oil or about 150 kg. of
products per Tibetan each year.
Transportation costs are so high for goods brought into Tibet, usually
by truck, that the central government subsidizes the retail price to
keep prices down to a reasonable level. The low productivity agriculture
and chronic money-losing industry of Tibet depend upon central
government subsidies to survive. In 1992, the central government subsidy
for Tibet amounted to 644 RMB per Tibetan. Compare this with the Chinese
national average per capita income of 630 RMB in that same year. (pp. 64
- 65).
Since 1990, agriculture and herding in Tibet have been free of taxes.
Free medical care, education, and improved living and health conditions
in Tibetan cities and towns as a result of central government subsidies
have made the cities and town more attractive to farmers. This has
spurred urbanization.
Ma Rong's Policy Recommendations:
o
Improve the quality of statistical work and especially
statistics on birth, death and migration -- The difficult
living environment of Tibet means that agriculture/herding
and industry in Tibet must depend on large subsidies from
the central government for a long time to come.
o
Family planning is therefore needed to bring the increase in
the Tibetan population should be brought under control.
According to actual conditions and the willingness of the
Tibetan people to accept such a policy, the 'family planning
policy' already implemented in the cities and towns should
be extended to the farm villages and pastoral regions.
Health and pharmaceutical services should be extended at the
same time in order to avoid incidents and allay the concerns
of the people.
o
Medical services should be improved to cut the death rate,
improve the health of the people. Lower infant mortality
will allay the concerns of the people about the health of
their children.
o
Foster development of ethnic handicraft industry,
development of small towns, and tourism
o
Strengthen control of statistics on and management of
in-migration.
o
Be prepared to restrict in-migration when necessary. Owing
to Tibet's small population, it has a limited capacity to
absorb a large influx of people from the outside. Ethnic and
religious considerations as well dictate that more research
should be undertaken immediately on the floating population
moving into Tibet. The question of in-migration to Tibet
should be addressed with care. (p. 67)
Bibliography of Recent Chinese Scholarship on Tibet on Embassy
Beijing Website
Many Chinese-language books on about the environment, economy and social
development of Tibet based on recent survey work have been published
since 1990. Some of this scholarship is not well known in the West. A
much longer list of over twenty recent Chinese-language scholarly books
on these subjects is maintained on the U.S. Embassy Beijing web site --
Recent Chinese Language Studies on Tibetan Society, Economy, Environment
and S&T <cid:[email protected]>
Most of these books are the product of social science fieldwork
conducted in Tibet since 1990.
"/Introduction to Environment and Development on the Qinghai Tibetan
Plateau/" [Qing Zang Gaoyuan Huanjing yu Fazhan Gailun] ed. by Luosan
Linzhidujie. Published May 1996 by Zhongguo Zangxue Chubanshe [China
Tibetan Studies Publishing House]. Chapters on geology, hydrology,
climate, soils, mineral, natural regions, economic development,
sustainable socio-economic development on the Qinghai Tibetan Plateau,
and "Plateau Modernization, Resources and Environment Policy". Published
as part of the Qinghai Tibetan Plateau Environment and Development Series.
"/Population and Society of Tibet/" [Xizang de Renkou yu Shehui] by Ma
Rong. Published December 1996 by Tongxin Chubanshe. Ma Rong, a professor
at the Social Anthropology Research Institute of Beijing University,
draws on both Chinese and English-language scholarship and government
statistics on Tibet. In this 450 page volume Ma examines topics such as
the geographical distribution and size of the various ethnic Tibetan
populations in China, the Han population residing in Tibet, Tibet's
population structure, migration into and out of the Tibetan Autonomous
Region, transformation of the Tibetan economy, income and consumption of
urban and rural Tibetans, marriage, education, and the relationship
between the ethnic Tibetan and ethnic Han residents of Tibet. Ma Rong
also wrote the thirty page essay on the Tibetans in the 1996 book
"Surveys and Research on China's Minority Populations" [Zhongguo Shaoshu
Minzue Diaocha Yanjiu] a summary of which is found on at the U.S.
Embassy Beijing web page at
http://www.redfish.com/USEmbassy-China/sandt/chimin.htm
Publisher's address: Tongxin Chubanshe is Xibiaobei Hutong #34, Dongdan
District, Beijing 100734.
"/Research on the Social Development of Tibet/" [Xizang Shehui Fazhan
Yanjiu], Edited by China Tibetan Studies Institute [Zhongguo Zangxue
Yanjiu Zhongxin] and the Socio-Anthropology Institute of Beijing
University. Zhongguo Zangxue Chubanshe [China Tibetan Studies Publishing
House] March 1997. The book is divided into Tibet's economic development
and Surveys on the population and regions of Tibet. Topics examined
include the development of traditional handicraft industries, the trade
and market for traditional handicraft industries, education, housing,
migration, the Han population of Tibet, and studies on people in various
regions of Tibet. ISBN 7-80057-321-4/F 17
"/Changes in Tibetan Family Structure Over Forty Years -- A Report on a
Study of One Hundred Tibetan Families/" [Xizang Jiating Sishi Nian
Bianqian -- Xizang Baijia Diaochao Baogao], Ed. by Socio-Economic
Studies Group at the China Tibetan Studies Institute and published by
the China Tibetan Studies Publishing House, July 1996. ISBN
7-80057-282-X/Z 145. Articles by individual researchers include "From
Migratory Herders to Fixed Settlement: Forty Years of Changes in the
Lives of Tibetan Herders", "Forty Years of Changes in the Lives of the
Anduo Family Herding Economics", "Changes in the Material Life of Herder
Families", "Herder Family and Women", changes in the lives of Tibetan
farmers over the past 40 years, population and marriage in Lugu district
of Lhasa, changes in the material life of Lhasa Lugu district residents,
religious life and education of Lhasa Lugu district residents, a study
on changes in Tibetan married life, changes in structure and function of
Tibetan families over the past forty years, changes in religious faith
of herders, farmers and urban residents over the past 40 years, Tibetan
politico-cultural concepts and participation in politics.
"/Tibet Forestry and Economy/" [Xizang Linye Jingji], ed. by Bai Chou.
Published March 1996 by Zhongguo Zangxue Chubanshe [China Tibetan
Studies Publishing House]. Chapters include Tibetan Forestry Economy
development and resources, Tibet forest creation and forestry
production, protection of Tibetan forestry resources, Tibetan forest
products industry, Tibetan wood distribution and the construction of the
market, the Tibetan Forestry economics system and forestry policy,
Tibetan forestry reform and development concepts and measures, and
forestry development on the middle reaches of the Yijiang Lianghe
region. Part of Tibetan Economic Research Series.
"/Reform and Development in the Agricultural and Herding Regions of
Tibet/" [Xizang Nongmuqu Gaige Yu Fazhan] , ed. by Xiao Huaiyuan,
published May 1994 by Zhongguo Zangxue Chubanshe [China Tibetan Studies
Publishing House]. Chapters include reform in the agricultural and
herding regions, the dual management system in the agricultural and
herding regions, construction of the combined collection and cooperative
economy, construction of the socialist service system in the
agricultural and herding regions, product distribution and market
development, investment and construction in the agricultural and herding
regions, multiple types of management and the township and village
enterprises, population and social security. Part of Tibetan Economic
Research Series.
"/Tibetan Hydrology and Industry/" [Xizang Shuili Chanyehua], ed. by Bai
Chou, published May 1996 by Zhongguo Zangxueyuan Chubanshe [China
Tibetan Studies Publishing House]. Chapters include location and use of
water resources, monitoring of industrial use of water resources,
investment and management of water resources, water pricing system,
urban and livestock water use, water laws and regulations. Part of
Tibetan Economic Research Series.
http://www.usembassy-china.org.cn/english/sandt/tibethrd.htm
© Copyright 2009 by Boxun News
Top of Page
|
|
 |

|